Teaching with AI 2: The role of humans in AI

Main Content and Description of the Learning Scenario

In this scenario, teachers reflect on the role of humans in an increasingly AI-shaped educational world. The central question is which human abilities can be supported by AI, but not replaced by it. Participants explore the limitations of AI and discuss why critical thinking, creativity, social intelligence, as well as ethics and responsibility remain central competencies for teachers and students.

The teacher or workshop facilitator introduces the topic and makes clear that AI can analyse large amounts of data, recognise patterns, process language, and create visual content, but does not truly understand, feel, think critically, or independently take ethical responsibility. Participants work through the worksheet in groups and transfer the discussion to concrete teaching situations.

Creator Lana Sattelmaier
Subject Teacher Professional Development
Length 30 min.
Pedagogical Approach Participatory learning
Competencies

C44 – Intelligence comparison
C66 – Limitations of AI
C81 – Human role
C83 – Ethical use of AI

Grade Teachers from all school types and subjects
Technologies Computers or tablets with internet access, projector, worksheet, optional digital whiteboard
Evaluation

Participants are assessed based on their active participation, their comparison of human and artificial intelligence, and their reflection on the limitations of AI as well as the importance of human abilities such as critical thinking, creativity, social intelligence, ethics, and responsibility.

Learning Activities

LA1: Introduction – AI and humans: Who can do what? (5 min)
The workshop facilitator introduces the guiding question: What can AI already do very well, and what remains human? Together, participants collect examples such as data analysis, pattern recognition, text generation, or image generation. Central limitations of AI are then discussed, such as the lack of real understanding, lack of empathy, and lack of ethical responsibility.

LA2: Individual reflection – Which abilities can AI not replace? (5 min)
Participants first consider individually which human abilities remain especially important in education and society. Possible examples include critical thinking, creativity, social intelligence, responsibility, judgement, and empathy.

LA3: Group work – Human vs. artificial intelligence (10 min)
Participants discuss in groups the areas in which AI is already more powerful than humans and which abilities are difficult or impossible for AI to replace. They fill in a table with human abilities, explanations, and examples from everyday life or teaching. The worksheet specifically names critical thinking, creativity, social intelligence, as well as ethics and responsibility.

LA4: Transfer to teaching practice (7 min)
The groups choose three abilities and discuss why these are especially important for teachers and students. They also consider how these abilities can be deliberately promoted in teaching and what risks arise when people rely too heavily on AI systems.

LA5: Final round – Sharing a key insight (3 min)
Each group shares one key insight with the plenary. Finally, the question is raised which new human abilities may become more important in the age of AI.

Materials

Presentation: DE0021 – REMIX – Quickstart AI for Teachers
Worksheet: DE0020 – The Role of Humans

 

 

 

 

Main Content and Description of the Learning Scenario

In this scenario, teachers reflect on the role of humans in an increasingly AI-shaped educational world. The central question is which human abilities can be supported by AI, but not replaced by it. Participants explore the limitations of AI and discuss why critical thinking, creativity, social intelligence, as well as ethics and responsibility remain central competencies for teachers and students.

The teacher or workshop facilitator introduces the topic and makes clear that AI can analyse large amounts of data, recognise patterns, process language, and create visual content, but does not truly understand, feel, think critically, or independently take ethical responsibility. Participants work through the worksheet in groups and transfer the discussion to concrete teaching situations.

Creator Lana Sattelmaier
Subject Teacher Professional Development
Length 30 min.
Pedagogical Approach Participatory learning
Competencies

C44 – Intelligence comparison
C66 – Limitations of AI
C81 – Human role
C83 – Ethical use of AI

Grade Teachers from all school types and subjects
Technologies Computers or tablets with internet access, projector, worksheet, optional digital whiteboard
Evaluation

Participants are assessed based on their active participation, their comparison of human and artificial intelligence, and their reflection on the limitations of AI as well as the importance of human abilities such as critical thinking, creativity, social intelligence, ethics, and responsibility.

Learning Activities

LA1: Introduction – AI and humans: Who can do what? (5 min)
The workshop facilitator introduces the guiding question: What can AI already do very well, and what remains human? Together, participants collect examples such as data analysis, pattern recognition, text generation, or image generation. Central limitations of AI are then discussed, such as the lack of real understanding, lack of empathy, and lack of ethical responsibility.

LA2: Individual reflection – Which abilities can AI not replace? (5 min)
Participants first consider individually which human abilities remain especially important in education and society. Possible examples include critical thinking, creativity, social intelligence, responsibility, judgement, and empathy.

LA3: Group work – Human vs. artificial intelligence (10 min)
Participants discuss in groups the areas in which AI is already more powerful than humans and which abilities are difficult or impossible for AI to replace. They fill in a table with human abilities, explanations, and examples from everyday life or teaching. The worksheet specifically names critical thinking, creativity, social intelligence, as well as ethics and responsibility.

LA4: Transfer to teaching practice (7 min)
The groups choose three abilities and discuss why these are especially important for teachers and students. They also consider how these abilities can be deliberately promoted in teaching and what risks arise when people rely too heavily on AI systems.

LA5: Final round – Sharing a key insight (3 min)
Each group shares one key insight with the plenary. Finally, the question is raised which new human abilities may become more important in the age of AI.

Materials

Presentation: DE0021 – REMIX – Quickstart AI for Teachers
Worksheet: DE0020 – The Role of Humans